CHARLIE PARR

Hollandale

2014-03-17

I'm sorry, Charlie Parr. It's not you, it's me. My ears just aren't developed enough to understand what you're doing, so your talents are wasted on me. I mean, I know you're making sounds on a guitar, and I know that Alan Sparhawk is accompanying you on guitar. I'm thinking this is some kind of improvisation rather than a set of pre-composed pieces. But I can't figure out what would make any of it interesting to other listeners.

I can't identify melody, or harmony, or rhythmic structure. There is no single instrumental voice to follow. I can't distinguish a progression, or figure out what makes this endless strumming something more directed than random. But these are all my faults, Charlie Parr, not yours.

To my ears, this is all appetizer without ever getting to entrée. Maybe the starts of these 5 pieces would work as the intro to something, but they drag on and on without resolving. It might work as music for a film, played under a sad little montage of a job applicant being rejected over and over and over again. And over again. At 42 minutes, this is fairly short for a CD (I understand it is also available on vinyl, so that's all that would fit), but I kept hoping it was over, and it wasn't. One day I'll learn to appreciate this.

According to Chaperone Records, Charlie Parr is known for folk and for roots music, and has quite a following, both within his home state of Minnesota and throughout the world.

--Gerald Etkind

Quick Links:

More reviews tagged #Folk

  • reviewed 09/2006

    CATIE CURTIS
    Long Night Moon

  • reviewed 05/2009

    KATIE MELUA
    Pictures

  • reviewed 01/2004

    Dar Williams
    The Beauty of the Rain

  • reviewed 04/2006

    Seth Bernard and Daisy May
    The Copper Country Quintet

  • reviewed 10/2015

    Caroline Aiken
    Broken Wings Heal

  • reviewed 07/2006

    WAILIN JENNYS
    Firecracker

Compiled by the WYCE Journalism Club

The opinions expressed in these reviews are those of the individual volunteers that submitted the article and do not necessarily reflect the views of WYCE or GRCMC; nor its staff, donors, or affiliates.