Mary Chapin Carpenter

The Calling

2007-04-16

When MCC hit the country-rock scene big time with “Down at the Twist and Shout” and the smash follow-up CD Come On, Come On, her observant lyrics analyzed the human heart with accuracy and a touch of wit. Since then, her songs have turned more toward the Big Questions, and in my opinion, lost some of the ability to capture the real moments of life and relationships. Surprisingly, the opposite is true on The Calling. The most interesting cuts are not about the heart, but about our country: “Houston” (Hurricane Katrina), “On with the Song” (the Dixie Chicks’ political troubles) and “Why Shouldn’t We” (on believing the nation can do better). The title track has some muscle, too. Maybe MCC’s turning a corner, from a musical Dear Abby to a lyrical editorial page columnist. We’ll see. 03/07 MJVD

More reviews tagged #Folk

  • reviewed 03/2004

    William Nowik
    Notes from the Underground

  • reviewed 07/2007

    The Pines
    Sparrows In The Bell

  • reviewed 07/2006

    GOLDEN SMOG
    Another Fine Day

  • reviewed 11/2006

    THE GOTHIC ARCHIES
    The Tragic Treasury

  • reviewed 07/2017

    Indoor Garden Party
    The Musical

  • reviewed 06/2011

    Black Jake and the Carnies
    Sundry Mayhems

Compiled by the WYCE Journalism Club

The opinions expressed in these reviews are those of the individual volunteers that submitted the article and do not necessarily reflect the views of WYCE or GRCMC; nor its staff, donors, or affiliates.